An unwinnable war essay

This kind of talk alarmed me because it discouraged a frank reassessment of our failing strategy in Iraq, which was producing that weekly procession of maimed veterans. Defeating the Communist guerrillas would have been an easy matter if the South Vietnamese people had refused to hide them in their midst.

In a recent New York Times articleMr. In South Vietnam itself, however, popular support for the war was always halfhearted, and a large segment and in some regions, a majority of the population favored the Communists. Just about the last thing he wanted was to engender a wartime psychology — much less call for full mobilization.

The corrupt, undemocratic and faction-riven South Vietnamese government — both under President Ngo Dinh Diem, who was assassinated in a coup, and under An unwinnable war essay military cliques that followed him — proved incapable of providing its people and armed forces a cause worth fighting for.

What put the final nail in the coffin, from my point of view, was when I learned from questioning [South Vietnamese] general officers that almost without exception their sons were in school in France, Switzerland, or the U.

But that would have required raising taxes, calling up the Reserves and other sacrifices that President Lyndon Johnson shrank from asking the American people to make. It was a heart-rending experience to see these young men and women, many of them missing eyes, arms, legs or even multiple limbs, being wheeled through the building.

But if Johnson admitted publicly that South Vietnam could not survive without a full commitment by the United States, he knew that support would crumble.

University Press of Kansas Blog

The Failure of Pacification and Vietnamization, The problem, the optimists argued, was that — just as during the Vietnam War — naysaying pundits and politicians were not merely undermining popular support for the war, but giving our enemies hope that they could win by waiting for the American people to lose their will to continue the fight.

There is a broad consensus among professional historians that the Vietnam War was effectively unwinnable. Sacrifice should not be demanded solely of those who risk life and limb for their country in combat theaters overseas.

Taking their cue from the Vietnam revisionists, Iraq war optimists argued that just as Americans thought we were losing in Vietnam when in fact we were winning, so too were we winning in Iraq despite apparent evidence to the contrary.

Some years after the war ended, Lt. But although psychological factors and popular support were crucial, it was Vietnamese, rather than American, attitudes that were decisive. Unfortunately for the United States and the future happiness of the South Vietnamese people, the Communists were more successful: And I also knew that the historical premises on which it was based were deeply flawed.

Those who made this argument contended that the United States had been on the verge of winning in Vietnam, but threw its chance for victory away because of negative press and a resulting failure of political will at home.Why Vietnam was Unwinnable; An Essay Posted on August 23, by Derek Helms By Kevin Boylan, author of Losing Binh Dinh: The Failure of.

- America's Role in the Vietnam War Before the 2nd World War, Vietnam was a colony of France.

During the war, French Indo China was occupied by the Japanese. When the war was over, the French took the place of the Japanese in Vietnam. The Vietnam War was fought during the cold war on 1 November - 30 April The Vietnam War was a war fought between the North and South Vietnam mainly, but in later year the US would join in to help South Vietnam ward off the communist mind of Ho Chi Minh and North Vietnam.

An argument that the war in Afghanistan is similar to the war in Vietnam, and cannot be won by the U.S.

Essay on The Solution to the Immoral, Unwinnable War on Drugs Words | 7 Pages policy has received sharp criticism from members of the law enforcement, as well as groups of parents and other constituencies who believe that the government should pursue the goal of a “drug-free” society.

An Unwinnable War Words | 7 Pages. As America find herself in today’s “War on Terrorism,” one can easily find a number of similarities between today’s situation and the war in Vietnam.

Vietnam: The Unwinnable War

As the Taliban steadily loses control and power over Afghanistan, it becomes exceedingly important to discuss potential replacement governments.

Download
An unwinnable war essay
Rated 4/5 based on 31 review